of the numerous stories, told in the gospels of john and luke- together over 6000 words-
6350 words, from the reception hosanna until pilate, (as explained in the previous post, link provided below, please see later]
very little of the "story" is supported by both witnesses!
if i begin with an empty page- what should i believe? the religion would demand i believe all of both stories, but I question- from the books themselves- what should i believe? read the two stories and see that only a bit is supported by both witnesses.
I begin the story "five days before" the crucifixion- when jesus entered-
on a colt? or on a donkey?
which he got before they said hosanna? or after??
we should stop expecting precision from books not provided by god.
///
***chapter one Reception
Jesus came toward Jerusalem, and people shouted "blessed is he who comes in the name of the lord, the messiah/christ". Later they ate and jesus said one who is here will assist my arrest and they asked each other about whom did he speak. Peter said "I will die with you" but jesus replied " I say to you, before the rooster crows you will deny me three times. then jesus went outside.
chapter 2 Arrest
Judas came with a group of soldiers and one person hit the slave of the high priest on the right ear and jesus said "enough". they grabbed jesus [in the dark].
chapter 3 peter denies
in a house owned by the high priest, a maidservant said about simon "he is one of jesus'-" but simon denied. they lit a fire [now or before the first denial?]and said to simon "you are his disciple" and he denied again. later, another said "he was with jesus" and petyer denied for the third time and then the rooster crowed.
chapter 4 pilate
in the morning etc.
we see that from john 12= the chapter of the reception, until pilate [chapters 12>18.29], and when compared with the longer chapters of luke 19.1-23.1 and totalling 6350 hebrew words [which are more efficient than the much greater number of english words, in the same section] only
***170 "words of story" are supported by both witnesses and in efficient hebrew words only 99-
only 99 hebrew words "of story" are supported by both witnesses.
when dealing with the numerous differences between the gospels and the stories- which are "not supported by both" and often conflict- we msut emphasize that these chapters are not a core faith of christianity- and still it shows that the books were written by people who made numerous errors.
so relying on the book themselves- one would see a short story supported by both of about 170 words- and not the numerous chapters of john and luke etc.
for background:
http://tomsawyerssongs.blogspot.co.il/2015/09/comparing-four-gospels.html
אין תגובות:
הוסף רשומת תגובה