יום שישי, 16 באוקטובר 2015

eras in jewish history

although some doubt that solomon built a temple- both opinions in encyclopedia brittanica support each other that the jews had a temple in jerusalem in the era of the israelite kings=monarchy of israel which according to the historian josephus lasted 466 years and this reliable historian said solomon built the temple, in book 20
the eras are:
wait! if the total is 83 priests then the seventy who overlapped as described in the story of jonatan and simon- were generations so if one marries age 18 like the tradition at that era, then the child is born when dad is 20 and his son born 20 years later therefore 70*20-1400 is believable we must see if he exagerated beyond 1400?
only 13 are claimed to be replaced after death leaving 70 hp by generation.
era 1 from depart 612 years [ with the error in the book 1 Kings chapter 6]
era 2 temple 466 years with "regal" king
era 3 70 years until cyrus added to the years of priests
era 4 democratic rule 414 years total about 900 which is much more !! plausible than 1400 showing josephus did not exagerate the eras
era 5 107 years from antiocus interfered until destruction by romans phanas hp [after caiphas in new testament not listed by name in the 28 from herod]
466+414+107= 990 years divided by 70 averaged about 14 years per high priest extending 1057 years. this challenges the talmudic tradition and josephus is the historian- therefore...
for details
one website claims josephus "listed" but he does not list more than 9+4.
Josephus (gives a list of) claims eighty-three high-priests from Aaron to the destruction of the Temple
in book 20 
Josephus: Jewish Antiquities, Book 20
and divides the history into eras
he also offers the reason for the loss of gods protection of the temple because of muderous robbers 20.8.5-6 
quote
"mingling themselves among the multitude, they slew certain of their own enemies, and were subservient to other men for money; and slew others, not only in remote parts of the city, but in the temple itself also; for they had the boldness to murder men there, without thinking of the impiety of which they were guilty. And this seems to me to have been the reason why God, out of his hatred of these men's wickedness" not for this group of murderers killing the high priest- who was a VICTIM not an evil high priest as some think
era 1
in 612 years from depart/exit egypt until "solomon " built the temple [not 480 because 1 Kings has error but 612] had 13 priests
and 70 high priests from temple until the roman war "until Phanas, who was made high priest during the war"
quote:
"Accordingly, the number of all the high priests from Aaron, of whom we have spoken already, as of the first of them, until Phanas, who was made high priest during the war by the seditious, was eighty-three-
83
of whom thirteen officiated as high priests in the wilderness, from the days of Moses, while the tabernacle was standing, until the people came into Judaea, when king Solomon erected the temple to God for at the first they held the high priesthood till the end of their life, although afterward they had successors while they were alive. Now these thirteen, who were the descendants of two of the sons of Aaron, received this dignity by succession, one after another; for their form of government was an aristocracy [...] Now the number of years during the rule of these thirteen, from the day when our fathers departed out of Egypt, under Moses their leader, until the building of that temple which king Solomon erected at Jerusalem, were six hundred and twelve.
***612 years and 13 life-long high priests
jsps continues to summarize the history- in the era of the first temple  466 years 18 people were appointed high priest
quote
"After those thirteen high priests, eighteen took the high priesthood at Jerusalem, one in succession to another, from the days of king Solomon, until Nebuchadnezzar, king of Babylon, made an expedition against that city, and burnt the temple, and removed our nation into Babylon, and then took Josadek, the high priest, captive- the times of these high priests were four hundred and sixty-six years, six months, and ten days, while the Jews were still under the regal government. 
***466 years and 18 high-priests
next an era with 15 hp, the 414 years from "rebuild" temple until the democratic rule ended- meaning the high priest leader was chosen by the people- to represent them [as described in war by jsps]
quote
"rebuild their temple at which time Jesus, the son of [the high priest] Josadek, took the high priesthood over the captives when they were returned home. Now he and his posterity, who were in all fifteen, until king Antiochus Eupator, were under a democratic government for four hundred and fourteen years
414 years with 15 high-priests
then king antiochus interfered and the asamoneans [in modern hebrew hashmonayim like hava=eve and kfar nahum- kparnaum]
beat the "macedonians" !! and made jonatan high priest and the family was royal kings.
quote
"But then the posterity of the sons of Asamonaeus, who had the government of the nation conferred upon them, when they had beaten the Macedonians in war, appointed Jonathan to be their high priest
under democratic meaning people choose high priest from the family of josadek who had been high priest at the time of the destruction of the temple
antiokus appointed [after 15 hp during 414 years] jaciemus
1 jaceimus
2 jonatan
3 simon
4 hyrcanus
5 judas
6 alexander both king and hp
7 hyrcanus 2
8 aristobulus fought removed h who called romans to interfere
7b h reinstated/restored
9 aristobulus 2 who king appointed, not democratic and not yet by lottery until later- 
and 28 more not listed but josephus does say "twenty eight" matching
83-13=70-18=52-15=37-9=28 from herod- not listed!

יום רביעי, 14 באוקטובר 2015

happy endings part 3 [final]

happy endings part 3 [and now- the conclusion]
=
until now we met a family of unknown race whose children tried to protect their father when arrested and those teens were punished for "obstructing" justice and other crimes.
after punishment the teens use "force" to free their father from prison- but all efforts to get attention from the authorities failed...
3
ajnef desperately videoed and uploaded a video to "social media" showing the hostage girl and the bomb
"this is real", ajnef announces on the video, in the local language, "we are in the city called ier and the bomb will explode in twenty minutes"
the title "hostage NOW" finally gets attention- several hundred views and comments and the r symbol for "like" and the police in ier are notified.
many people reply with comments
some say:
do not be violent
do not use force 
what do you want
that is so cool you are so brave
etc. etc.
the police began searching the city of Ier, house to house and building to building, knowing the timer has only twenty minutes to search the entire city for the rescue mission
one reply annoyed naju "fish have water to live in, they already have- they do not need more water- imagine if fish tried to cover the entire surface with water for themselves"-
naju wrote a reply: "we do not want land! we can buy land and even owned land, before we were punished. we demand our father released from prison."
five minutes pass... but no reply promises to free their father
when 15 minutes remain ajnef uploads the next video this time showing the countdown from 15.00 to 14.01 and says free my father NOW or the girl dies.
five minutes pass... but no reply promises to free their father
nuja saw movement out the window- 
[the police are nearing their apartment building- if they rescue the girl the plan is ruined...]
officer kesea ordered his team of police into the apartment building at the corner of maple and pine streets the adress: 12 maple street. Ier city. 
the team split up and knocked on each door in the apartment building. the occupants opened the doors and allowed the police to search all the rooms, but none looked like the the room in the video.
more importantly they could not see the girl nor her captives.
officer kesea called in "we are running out of time free their father"
dispatch replied "i do not want to- if the man is in prison he probably deserved it and the judgement has been decreed"
"you can save a life"
" I do not believe they will free the hostage anyway, do not be naive that they will save the girls life when we give them what they want"
"other terrorists kept their word when they got what they wanted"
"i do not want to. now keep searching" instructed dispatch called "operations"
maenwhile dispatch wrote a reply politically correct "we apologize for the judge who cauesed you this pain but we cannot erase the judges decree of punishment" as operations clicked publish- the representative cussed i hate lying like this i really do not want to give them what they want.
nuja watched the timer run down to nine minutes while ajnef watched the police exit building twelve and continue on the same side of the street building 14 directly across from their building [due to bad planning the address was 27 maple street beside 15 maple street]
the police continued searching the same side of the street apartment by apartment
nuja said: "we should give more time- the whole point is to get papa out"
ajnef said they will learn their lesson
"but that is not what we want to accomplish! we do not care about this specific girl!"
as nuja approached to update the timer, ajnef pulled the same knife she had before, from the kitchen, and stabbed her disloyal brother. she comforted herself saying loudly: "any more time and the police will free her, and added now "him at peace" - as the sorceress in pirates of carribean said [at worlds end 2007]
ajnef watched out the window as the police came out of the building directly opposite them she checked the replies for a reply about her father and a video showing him free but there was none. ajnef shook the sleeping girl and said "i cannot live in a world like this" and holding the sleeping girls hands waited the last two minutes...
officer kesea finished searching the apartments in 14 maple and went down the stairs. he led his troops out of the building and as they regrouped on the sidewalk facing 27 maple, the bomb exploded. a flash of bright yellow from the window across the street caught the eyes of the team of searchers and the glass blasted out with a roar and two skulls with black burnt long hair.
the end.

יום חמישי, 8 באוקטובר 2015

happy endings part 2

happy endings part 2
until now we met a family of unknown race whose children tried to protect their father when arrested and those teens were punished for "obstructing" justice and other crimes.
how they got explosives? i do not know but the fact is we do see that "somehow " those who want to be terrorists have bombs.
we continue chapter 2 with the kids who finished their prison sentences holding an explosive- a deadly bomb. how did they get the bomb? I do not know how. somehow those who want to be terrorists- "somehow" have deadly bombs. my theory is that a bird flies to those who pray and the stork drops the package through the window.
2
ajnef and nuja traveled to the city named pisgat arye and entered the window [lesson: lock your windows!] of a home of a stranger. they locked the window behind them.
they crawled stealthily through the rooms and saw it was empty so they set up- by clearing a space in the room and and gathering chairs together. finally they checked that all the windows were locked.
after school ended, they heard the key turning in the lock and a ten year old girl came in. nuja was ready with a wooden bar and knocked the child unconscious. why? he wanted to do "anything" to free his father from prison. the goal justifies the "means" of how to achieve it.
the sleeping pills which they had crushed were mixed with water and dripped into the victims mouth, and then they tied the sleeping body to a chair. the head of blond hair hung limply.
ajnef rewarded her brother with a cigarette [lesson: cigarettes are associated with BAD and are dangerous and harmful] for not being a coward, but did not want to wait for the parents.
ajnef took the girls key and went to a public phone nearby and called the police "we have a hostage and we will kill her unless you free my father from prison within a half hour"
"that is what they all say" click.
ajnef tried again, dialing the 911 of her country and when they answered said: hello?
"please hold"
NO-!! ajnef hollered in frustration.
she ran back to the home and knocked the code knock.
nuja saw his sister and opened the door she grabbed a kitchen knife and went to kill the girl-
WAIT shouted nuja we want to get papa free! we cannot kill our hostage yet!
ajnef cussed and started crying in frustration. [lesson: not everyone who cries deserves your encouragement nor support].
nuja called his buddy to report to the police that they have a hostage and deliver the demands.
icsaj entered the police station in pisgat zev and shouts "i have information about a hostage!"
"calm down, you ar escaring everyone- wait for your turn" 
"how can you not care! they are going to kill a ten year old girl"
"nobody is going to kill anybody" they reassure him in fact if you keep "disturbing the peace we will arrest you"
"arrest me? what the puck?? okay arrest me and take me to questioning" a cop placed metal vise on a hand and clipped the other end to the bench and said "wait your turn"
"but the bomb is counting down"
to be continued...

יום רביעי, 7 באוקטובר 2015

happy endings

happy endings
1 the plan
nuja and ajnef watched as the police walked toward the door of their warm home. nuja had noticed movement through the wide and tall window of the entrance hall and quickly grabbed the remote control to close the curtains. he pressed the button and with a dull wirr the loosely-weaved net of curtain spread across the broad window from both sides. ajnef had heard the wirr and hurried into the room.
they had peared through the net of curtain to watch as two police officers, one with a bulging shirt near the waist and the other with a bulging shirt near the shoulders, walked on the start of the red s of the path leading from the wide public sidewalk until their door.
note: the letter "s" like any letter means "something shaped like the letter" [meriam webster]
ajnef was a 19 year old girl who had walked to school every morning but almost never actually entered it. at graduation she was punished severely for not graduating.
now she criticised the police for not staying on the marked path of the artistic and smooth s of the red-brick path but walked straight, first over the red and then on the white concrete and again over the red and again over the white, toward the door.  she cussed at those "uncivilised barbarians".
the police knocked on the door and ajnef grabbed a metal statuette from on the decorative square table near the door, the one which had a shallow rectangular drawer along the length of it, in which they put their key when they entered. nuja ordered "put that back" but ajnef ever rebellious, as we recognize it, and free as she called it, defended her actions as "self defense".
"do not be stupid!" scolded her brother "these are police! they will bring even more trouble if you resist".
"I don't care!" she answered.
the bell rang again and the police shouted a warning "if you do not open the door, we will break it down"
"such violent uncivilized brutes," she hissed.
nuja reached out to turn the handle of the door, but she pushed him violently away from the door.
CRASH
the beautiful wooden door split apart with hammers as ajnef hollered "you will pay for those damages"
"tell it to the judge", snapped the officer who looked female. the police officer who appeared to be a fat man ordered: "get hapfa jociv, now!"
"or else what" shouted ajnef, as she gently lowered her self defense weapon back to the table top. 
"he is not home now" nuja lied as he lay on the floor.
"resistance is useless" said the cops in unison, "now stand up and get him!"
nuja began crawling away as ajnef hollered "coward ! you were always the coward" the officer who looked like a woman agilely scooped the crawling man up and snapped a metal vise on his wrist. the man grabbed the girl's left arm as she hollered "rapist! get your sex-pervert hands off of me" and as she swung the metal statuette at his face, in self-defense!
resistance was futile.
he skillfully blocked her arm and the statuette rebounded backward, his fist continued towards her face and pounded into her cheek.
the rest of the squad had been there for backup, because they had learned from past experience that sometimes racism is true and prejudices are true. they had played the act of not being prejudice by sending two officers, just like when they arrested their own race but this race just made their crimes more and more severe.
they saw through the cameras that the two teens were resisting and "interfering" with the arrest of their father and that ,meant that these two required punishments as well. they ran in to support and as backup to help the two againstg two however the police had been trained weell in these skills and easily subdued the two teens. the backup escorted them to the police van. naju docile but ajnef never submitting pulling on her wrist cuff until her skin ripped open and blood dripped which made her angrier and louder as she pulled in every direction and tried to hit the cops with her free hand. another officer zapped her with the electric taser and with a gloved hand supported her back as she was pushed into the van and tied securely.
meanwhile the two officers in the house searched the house. they had studied the layout and threw tear gas packets down the hallways but then the radio announced we got him so they went out through the front door and met the team in the back who had seen him climb out a back window and had shot him because he held a gun. the team in the back had also shot a total of six of the neighbors when they saw the long narrow poles of the rifles poking out the windows.
the hospital removed the bullet from hapfa and they operated to save his life for the trial in which all were given severe punishments. the judge wrote "the crime of hapfa deserves the death penalty which exists in this country but as judge i value each life and commute the punishment to only five years in the hotel because we are also demolishing the house as part of the punishment.
the teens were sent to a different hotel to work for six months and none could leave the hotels they were required to work in. unsurprisingly after the siblinghs had made their plans for revenge and moreimportantly to compel the early release of their father ajnef tried to escape from her work. as she stepped out of the hotel door the security gaurd who not only watched those entering  zapped her in the back with a taser and she was shipped to a prison cell for-
ten additional months, more than the original sentence.
naju was released on schedule, and forgetting his home had been demolished asked the taxi to drive him from  the hotel which he had been required to work in and forbidden to leave for the entire span of months, to the street in pisgat zev a wealthy neighborhood in the city.
the taxi driver refused because the locals had been throwing rocks but agreed to drive until the neighborhood. as they neared the neighborhood nuja jumped out without paying. based on past experiences there had been a camera in the taxi and this immoral act of not paing for a service was recorded. before nuja even reached the now empty lot which had once been a very fancy home, the local unit of police officers arrested him again and sent him back to the hotel to work another month.
to be continued.

יום רביעי, 30 בספטמבר 2015

holiday season

this year jewish holidays coincide with muslim holidays
on september 15 the jews celebrated the jewish new year of the hebrew calendar-
I criticize this because it is not the new year that god told the jewish prophets-
what happens at the new year? the number for the year went up by one.
near it is the jewish holiday of yom kippur-
a day when many jews "deny themselves" from eating and drinking by fasting.
it was ten days after the new year which I also criticise for several reasons mainly that denying is not a commant to  fast an the tradition has five options how to deny among other problems.
at that time the muslims celebrated the holiday of sacrifice on 23 september of 2015
"Eid al-Adha in 2015 is on Wednesday, the 23rd of September. Based on sightability in North America, in 2015 Eid al-Adha will start in North America a day later"
 according to muslim faith the focus is that ibrahim called abraham by christians- sacrificed his son- the quran does not say which son. but the point is as above.
however muslims emphasizee on their websites that the version in the christian bible is false-
http://www.whyislam.org/submission/five-pillars-of-islam-2/pilgrimage/festival-of-the-sacrifice/
" the sacrifice that God (Allah) commanded to Prophet Abraham of his beloved son, Ismail."
this is significant and has caused many muslims who know the quran to abandon islam because they know that the quran requires "to read wisdom from the books of moses and jesus" and when the muslim religious leaders say that this is the holiday- they are aware of the problem that they are required to get wisdom from the book of moses- and therefore it was not ismail but isac and they know the leader lied to them and those who value truth and believe in the holy quran are required by it to read the books of moses and jesus and therefore leave the lies of the muslim leaders.
one other possibility is to claim as the muslim leaders tell those who ask that the "truth" is ismail while the books of moses are corrupt- assuming this is true the holy quran "would not" direct to read the "corrupt" book of moses and clearly the books of moses are "not corrupt" specifically according to the quran leading many muslims to publish this logic and convert to christianity
!!

יום ראשון, 20 בספטמבר 2015

equinox

1first the day which has a length of 12 hours exactly for equal day and night is identified as september 27 this year.
2second the month based on the moon [called lunar] ended september 13 at 10 am, [after almost 30 days= 29 days and 15 hours] therefore the new month should begin on september 13 and be called the first of the lunar month- but instead the jewish lunar calendar made the new month 14 and "maybe" 15 of september when there can be no dount about 15 and even 14 is the wrong date because the previous month ended august 14 at 6 pm [at my coast]and if we assume that on that same "evening" begins the new month then 15 is first and 31 is 17 of lunar and september 1 would be called 18 and 12 of september would end the month with 29 days- like the rule "most months elul is not extra" in rashi and then that night would begin the first of the month-lunar called 13 september far from 15- there can be no doubt about 15 and even 14 is a day off so the calendar is not lunar- but delayed and the true first of the month for the new year should have been september 13 and therefore the fourteenth was the "wrong day" and besides we should compare to the chinese
http://www.timeanddate.com/calendar/about-chinese.html
august 14 began the chinese 7 month while the jewish calendar was again wrong with a two day error! continuing two more days to the "lunar" month- shameful!
14 and 15 were called the old lunar month way too long! while the chinese lunar was not only earlier but matching the moon because the cycle ended on the 14 and that same evening the like sabath begins in evening and certainly not a long month of 29 and 30 for the lunar which resulted in delaying the celebration of new year to the wrong date relative to the moon-
the seventh month had 30 days ending on the day we call saturday september 12 and the new month hence should begin september 13 as the first of the month and new year and if we start at evening like sabath then if so end sept 12 means that at the end of 12 begins the new year and the jew s"missed" the lunar date! and celebrated and did all the long ceremonies on the wromg day-
so better to ignore the "special" dates because they cannot get it "correctly" ="cant get it right".
=
3is gregorian any better? only in some ways however 21 of september is called equinox but actualy the days length is still longer than the night- 12 and aquarter hours- today september 20 12.15.40 from the time we call 6.40 until 18.57
and 21 6.42-18.55 not the "technical" equinox of new york!
even four days later september 25 the day is "too long" and september 26 is the "technical equinox and should be marked as a "special" unique day both in new york city new york not september 21 which is merely an "average" and not even the 23 as a reliable website claimed for that location new york
http://www.timeanddate.com/calendar/seasons.html?n=179
instead september twenty six the day is from 6.47-18.47 at 40-41 degrees north and whether 32-33 degrees north
september 25 6.31-18.34 too long so 27 is the equinox this year but usualy 26 indicating the need for a leap year day which will be provded! february 29, of 2016
=
4
following my surprise upon seeing your jordan map- that you took sides on the jordan map- i felt the need to open your syria map and was appalled that you ignored the 1973 cease-fire agreement between israel and syria- see below, and showed syria  as if syria includes the coast of the sea of galilee at 33 degrees north, please do not ignore the local cease-fire agreement! of 31 may 1974 see below- and mark the cease-fire line as agreed upon by the two sides- syria and israel.
"A disengagement agreement with Syria was signed in Geneva on 31 May 1974. It included exchange of prisoners of war, limitation on armed forces, Israeli withdrawal from territory that was captured in the 1973 war" == 
thank you
sources:
https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1969-76v26/d88
https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1969-76v26/ch2
and even israel admitted they gave some
http://www.mfa.gov.il/mfa/aboutisrael/maps/pages/yom%20kippur%20war%20cease-fire%20lines-%20october%2024-%201973.aspx
map "secret" at http://www.nevo.co.il/law_html/law09/amana-0851.pdf
https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1969-76v26/d88

eq v new v 29v 

יום חמישי, 10 בספטמבר 2015

jesus with pilate

what, in the book of john, is supported by a second witness?
**then, at dawn, they led jesus to pilat and accused. pilat asked jesus "Are you the king of the Jews?"
[...] [the replies do not match because what appears in john is not supported by luke]
pilat said, "I find no basis for a charge against this man." +what pilat said, according to john, is supported in luke, but what happened between? 
why did pilat ignore the accusations? the way the books are, demonstrates flawed originals- my solution follows the analysis.
analysis
1 did high priest question jesus? maybe! john 18.19+24 said yes and repeat "from high priest" 18.28 after rooster j18.27 and luke did not contradict.
(Luke 23:1 NIV) Then -[=minus]the Xwhole assembly Xrose and 
*led him to Pilate+
(John 18:28 NIV) Then (the Jews)
*led Jesus (from Caiaphas) *to (the palace of the Roman governor. By now it was early morning, and to avoid ceremonial uncleanness the Jews did not enter the palace; they wanted to be able to eat the Passover.John 18:29 NIV So) *Pilate. 
note: if luke denied the bit about the high priest, then it is consistent that he does not say "from".
john adds it is morning- matching the rooster crow in both versions. 
they wanted to eat the passover- is consistent in john, but according to luke they ate it before the rooster crowed! no need to "be able to eat the passover" 
!!
this is a critical problem about the core story CORE story of death- on the day of the passover is false if he ate the passover at its day as luke 22.7
to value the truth- is to deny both versions.
according to luke, they accuse, jesus admits he is king and pilate decides not guilty?
(Luke 23:2 NIV) they began to *accuse him, saying, "We have found this man subverting our nation. He opposes payment of taxes to Caesar and claims to be Christ, a king."(Luke 23:3 NIV) So Pilate asked Jesus, "Are you the king of the Jews?" "Yes, it is as you say," Jesus replied.(Luke 23:4 NIV) Then Pilate announced to the chief priests and the crowd, "I find no basis for a charge against this man."
note until "no basis" only sixty words.
why did pilate free him- if he said he is king? agreeing to the accusations. it is much shorter than john until pilates decision-
the key difference is that in john he says to be a king of a different world- not competing with the ceasar. this is what requires editing, however the two versions support each other very little.
compare
-Xcame out to them and Xasked, "What charges are you bringing against this man?" (John 18:30 NIV) "If he were not a criminal," they Xreplied, "we would not have handed him over to you."  (John 18:31 NIV) Pilate Xsaid, "Take him yourselves and judge him by your own law." "But we have no right to execute anyone," the Jews objected. (John 18:32 NIV) This happened so that the words Jesus had spoken indicating the kind of death he was going to die would be fulfilled. John 18:33 NIV) Pilate then went back inside the palace, summoned Jesus and 
*asked him, "Are you the king of the Jews?"  
(John 18:34 NIV) "Is that your own idea," Jesus Xasked, "or did others talk to you about me?"  (John 18:35 NIV) "Am I a Jew?" Pilate Xreplied. "It was your people and your chief priests who handed you over to me. What is it you have done?"  (John 18:36 NIV) Jesus said, "My kingdom is not of this world. If it were, my servants would fight to prevent my arrest by the Jews. But now my kingdom is from another place."  (John 18:37 NIV) "You are a king, then!" said Pilate. Jesus answered, "You are right in saying I am a king. In fact, for this reason I was born, and for this I came into the world, to testify to the truth. Everyone on the side of truth listens to me."  (John 18:38 NIV) "What is truth?" Pilate asked. With this he went out again to the Jews and said, "I find no basis for a charge against him.
until "no basis" much more than 60. 218 words just in this section alone j18.34-38 and nothing in j is supported by l! it is supported by the prejudice called faith- but none of these details are supported by luke.
faith would be to say all details are true- they accused and pilate asked and they said he criminal and he questioned jesus, however-
a book that said jesus said "give to ceasar" should not have them saying "not pay taxes" and it is appropriate for john to leave that out. john adds that they want to kill him and cant.
from these 278 words, which details are supported?
l they accuse, but skips pilat ask- and the accusations do not match- j criminal who deserves death yet l king. not even one detail in j is supported by l with different details.
why in j does pilat ask about king? he was not accused of king- the book is flawed. compare: (Luke 23:2 NIV) And they began to *accuse him, Xsaying, "We have found this man Xsubverting our nation. He Xopposes payment of taxes to Caesar and claims to be Christ, a 
*king."(Luke 23:3 NIV) So Pilate asked Jesus, "Are you the king of the Jews?" 
until pilate asked r u king not even one detail matches. 
what is supported?
**then, at dawn, they led jesus to pilat and accused. pilat asked jesus "Are you the king of the Jews?" 
only the question matches but is not appropriate to the accusations of that book and worse the answers of jesus do not match- and he did "open his mouth" but what did he answer?
luke yes, but lacks ask yet in john jesus asks.
perhaps jesus did not answer anything and that is why john and luke each guessed what happened-
so my solution is "jesus did not open his mouth"
according to john jesus answers it is NOT "as you say" but a different king! not the same as pilat means- Xas and Xyou
to repair the two versions requires some editing!
how will pilate hear if jesus does not open his mouth?
pilate summons judas to ask what did he teach- judas sways pilate with the truth.
without these edits the books are flawed and christians base faith on flawed books.
**conclusion: [Jesus did not open his mouth. so Pilate asked the priests to bring his students, to ask what jesus taught, and they knew judas and called him. judas said that jesus taught "My kingdom is not of this world" so] pilat said, "I find no basis for a charge against this man."
comparison: "Yes, it is Xas you say," Jesus replied.(Luke 23:4 NIV) Then Pilate Xannounced to the chief priests and the crowd, "I find no basis for a charge against this man." sources: http://mppres.org/bible/john/
http://mppres.org/bible/Luke/Luke23.htm